| Date | Game | Home | Result | Away | |
| 17-09-24 | FAT | Sheffield | 2 - 3 |
Loughborough Students | |
| 07-09-24 | FAT | Sheffield | 0 - 1 |
Loughborough Students | |
| 23-09-23 | FAT | Hanley Town | 2 - 1 |
Sheffield | |
| 09-09-23 | FAT | Sheffield | 1 - 1 (4-2 p) |
Spalding United | |
| 24-09-22 | FAT | Sheffield | 1 - 1 (2-4 p) |
Ossett United | |
| 14-09-22 | FAT | City of Liverpool | 0 - 0 (2-4 p) |
Sheffield | |
| 09-10-21 | FAT | Bridlington Town | 3 - 3 (5-4 p) |
Sheffield | |
| 17-10-20 | FAT | Sheffield | 2 - 3 |
Runcorn Linnets FC | |
| 28-09-19 | FAT | Clitheroe | 2 - 1 |
Sheffield | |
| 02-10-18 | FAT | Prescot Cables | 6 - 2 |
Sheffield | |
| 29-09-18 | FAT | Sheffield | 2 - 2 |
Prescot Cables | |
| 07-10-17 | FAT | Sheffield | 0 - 3 |
Frickley Athletic | |
| 08-10-16 | FAT | Ramsbottom United | 3 - 1 |
Sheffield | |
| 31-10-15 | FAT | Marine | 1 - 0 |
Sheffield | |
| 03-10-15 | FAT | Sheffield | 4 - 1 |
Trafford | |
| 01-11-14 | FAT | Sheffield | 0 - 1 |
Witton Albion | |
| 18-10-14 | FAT | Stocksbridge Park Steels | 3 - 4 |
Sheffield |