| Date | Game | Home | Result | Away | |
| 11-05-24 | FAT | Gateshead | 2 - 2 (5-4p) |
Solihull Moors | |
| 06-04-24 | FAT | Gateshead | 2 - 1 |
Macclesfield | |
| 09-03-24 | FAT | Gateshead | 3 - 2 |
Peterborough Sports | |
| 10-02-24 | FAT | Hereford FC | 0 - 1 |
Gateshead | |
| 13-01-24 | FAT | Gateshead | 2 - 2 (4-3 p) |
Weston-super-Mare | |
| 12-12-23 | FAT | Rochdale | 1 - 5 |
Gateshead | |
| 21-05-23 | FAT | Gateshead | 0 - 1 |
FC Halifax Town | |
| 01-04-23 | FAT | Gateshead | 3 - 3 (4-1 p) |
Barnet FC | |
| 11-03-23 | FAT | Gateshead | 0 - 0 (4-2 p) |
Farsley Celtic | |
| 11-02-23 | FAT | Banbury United | 0 - 1 |
Gateshead | |
| 14-01-23 | FAT | Gateshead | 3 - 1 |
Oldham Athletic | |
| 20-12-22 | FAT | Gateshead | 5 - 1 |
Gloucester City | |
| 27-11-21 | FAT | AFC Fylde | 1 - 0 |
Gateshead | |
| 15-12-20 | FAT | Gateshead | 2 - 3 |
Farsley Celtic | |
| 23-11-19 | FAT | Halesowen Town | 1 - 0 |
Gateshead | |
| 18-12-18 | FAT | Salford City | 3 - 1 |
Gateshead | |
| 24-03-18 | FAT | Gateshead | 1 - 1 |
Bromley | |
| 17-03-18 | FAT | Bromley | 3 - 2 |
Gateshead | |
| 06-03-18 | FAT | Gateshead | 3 - 2 |
Leyton Orient | |
| 24-02-18 | FAT | Leyton Orient | 3 - 3 |
Gateshead | |
| 06-02-18 | FAT | Gateshead | 3 - 0 |
Maidstone United | |
| 03-02-18 | FAT | Maidstone United | 2 - 2 |
Gateshead | |
| 16-01-18 | FAT | Boreham Wood | 1 - 2 |
Gateshead | |
| 13-01-18 | FAT | Gateshead | 3 - 3 |
Boreham Wood | |
| 20-12-17 | FAT | Gateshead | 2 - 1 (a.e.t.) |
Guiseley | |
| 14-01-17 | FAT | Gateshead | 1 - 3 |
Lincoln City | |
| 10-12-16 | FAT | Gateshead | 2 - 0 |
Kings Lynn Town | |
| 02-03-16 | FAT | Gateshead | 3 - 3 (4-5 p) |
FC Halifax Town | |
| 27-02-16 | FAT | FC Halifax Town | 0 - 0 |
Gateshead | |
| 06-02-16 | FAT | Gateshead | 1 - 0 |
AFC Fylde | |
| 16-01-16 | FAT | Eastleigh | 1 - 2 |
Gateshead | |
| 12-12-15 | FAT | Gateshead | 4 - 1 |
Stocksbridge Park Steels | |
| 27-01-15 | FAT | Gateshead | 2 - 2 (3–5 p) |
Wrexham | |
| 24-01-15 | FAT | Wrexham | 1 - 1 |
Gateshead | |
| 13-01-15 | FAT | Gateshead | 3 - 2 (a.e.t.) |
Grimsby Town | |
| 10-01-15 | FAT | Grimsby Town | 0 - 0 |
Gateshead | |
| 13-12-14 | FAT | Gateshead | 2 - 0 |
Halesowen Town |