| Date | Game | Home | Result | Away | |
| 09-09-23 | FAT | Loughborough Dynamo | 1 - 1 (5-3 p) |
AFC Rushden & Diamonds | |
| 08-10-22 | FAT | AFC Rushden & Diamonds | 0 - 4 |
Tamworth | |
| 30-10-21 | FAT | Matlock Town | 2 - 1 |
AFC Rushden & Diamonds | |
| 08-12-20 | FAT | AFC Rushden & Diamonds | 1 - 5 |
Peterborough Sports | |
| 09-11-19 | FAT | South Shields | 4 - 0 |
AFC Rushden & Diamonds | |
| 29-10-19 | FAT | Banbury United | 1 - 2 |
AFC Rushden & Diamonds | |
| 26-10-19 | FAT | AFC Rushden & Diamonds | 0 - 0 |
Banbury United | |
| 10-11-18 | FAT | Witton Albion | 2 - 0 |
AFC Rushden & Diamonds | |
| 27-10-18 | FAT | AFC Rushden & Diamonds | 2 - 1 |
St Ives Town | |
| 07-10-17 | FAT | AFC Rushden & Diamonds | 1 - 3 |
Kidsgrove Athletic | |
| 15-11-16 | FAT | Lincoln United | 2 - 0 |
AFC Rushden & Diamonds | |
| 12-11-16 | FAT | AFC Rushden & Diamonds | 3 - 3 |
Lincoln United | |
| 29-10-16 | FAT | AFC Rushden & Diamonds | 1 - 0 |
Coalville Town | |
| 11-10-16 | FAT | Histon | 1 - 6 |
AFC Rushden & Diamonds | |
| 08-10-16 | FAT | AFC Rushden & Diamonds | 1 - 1 |
Histon | |
| 03-10-15 | FAT | AFC Rushden & Diamonds | 1 - 3 |
Basford United |