| Date | Game | Home | Result | Away | |
| 02-09-23 | FAC | Worksop | 4 - 1 |
Sheffield | |
| 19-08-23 | FAC | Sheffield | 2 - 1 |
Skegness Town | |
| 20-08-22 | FAC | Sheffield | 0 - 1 |
Glossop North End | |
| 06-08-22 | FAC | Eccleshill United | 0 - 4 |
Sheffield | |
| 21-08-21 | FAC | Sheffield | 1 - 2 |
Sherwood Colliery | |
| 22-09-20 | FAC | Coalville Town | 2 - 0 |
Sheffield | |
| 12-09-20 | FAC | Holbeach United | 0 - 4 |
Sheffield | |
| 07-09-19 | FAC | Rushall Olympic | 3 - 1 |
Sheffield | |
| 24-08-19 | FAC | Sheffield | 2 - 1 |
Litherland REMYCA | |
| 25-08-18 | FAC | Hyde United | 5 - 1 |
Sheffield | |
| 19-08-17 | FAC | Sheffield | 0 - 2 |
Ossett Town (defunct) | |
| 03-09-16 | FAC | Sheffield | 0 - 3 |
Farsley Celtic | |
| 20-08-16 | FAC | Ramsbottom United | 1 - 2 |
Sheffield | |
| 04-09-15 | FAC | Sheffield | 0 - 3 |
Goole | |
| 29-08-15 | FAC | Goole | 1 - 1 |
Sheffield | |
| 30-09-14 | FAC | Sheffield | 1 - 3 |
Warrington Town | |
| 27-09-14 | FAC | Warrington Town | 0 - 0 |
Sheffield | |
| 13-09-14 | FAC | Sheffield | 3 - 2 |
Shepshed Dynamo | |
| 02-09-14 | FAC | Sheffield | 2 - 1 (a.e.t.) |
Basford United | |
| 30-08-14 | FAC | Basford United | 3 - 3 |
Sheffield |