| 2 |
York City (1) |
1837 |
| 9 |
FC Halifax Town (1) |
1749 |
| 24 |
Scunthorpe United (2) |
1687 |
| 47 |
Scarborough Athletic (2) |
1565 |
| 82 |
Guiseley (3) |
1470 |
| 128 |
Whitby Town (3) |
1380 |
| 141 |
Farsley Celtic (2) |
1371 |
| 147 |
Cleethorpes Town (4) |
1359 |
| 182 |
Stocksbridge Park Steels (4) |
1312 |
| 223 |
Emley AFC (4) |
1250 |
| 238 |
Bradford Park Avenue (4) |
1231 |
| 241 |
North Ferriby (4) |
1229 |
| 258 |
Pontefract Collieries FC (4) |
1212 |
| 265 |
Garforth Town (4) |
1200 |
| 281 |
Ossett United (4) |
1180 |
| 289 |
Grimsby Borough (4) |
1167 |
| 294 |
Brighouse Town (4) |
1159 |
| 310 |
Bridlington Town (4) |
1129 |
| 315 |
Liversedge (4) |
1117 |
| 324 |
Sheffield (4) |
1096 |