VS
| Date | Res | Home | Score | Away | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 23 Sep 23 | W | Carlton Town | 2–1 | Chasetown | FA Trophy |
| 02 Apr 22 | W | Carlton Town | 2–0 | Chasetown | |
| 20 Nov 21 | D | Chasetown | 2–2 | Carlton Town | |
| 03 Mar 20 | D | Carlton Town | 2–2 | Chasetown | |
| 05 Oct 19 | W | Chasetown | 0–2 | Carlton Town | |
| 24 Mar 18 | L | Chasetown | 3–0 | Carlton Town | |
| 02 Dec 17 | L | Carlton Town | 2–4 | Chasetown | |
| 10 Dec 16 | W | Carlton Town | 3–1 | Chasetown | |
| 08 Nov 16 | L | Chasetown | 1–0 | Carlton Town | |
| 08 Oct 16 | W | Carlton Town | 3–1 | Chasetown | FA Trophy |
| 27 Feb 16 | L | Chasetown | 2–0 | Carlton Town | |
| 17 Oct 15 | L | Carlton Town | 2–3 | Chasetown | |
| 10 Jan 15 | W | Carlton Town | 1–0 | Chasetown | |
| 04 Oct 14 | W | Chasetown | 0–3 | Carlton Town |
